Page 1 of 3

Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 3:31 pm
by Panther2856
Hiya Forum,

May I ask what material would be better to fish over rough ground with, using a pulley pennel rig, a 60lb tapered shockleader, 170 gram lead, and a 15ft emcast fixed spool rod please.


I am debating over these two items :


, 30lb braid


and,


,18lb mono


Thankyou,


Panther2856

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 3:45 pm
by prawnster
In my (limited) experience, and I have fished with both, braid is better for bite detection and the lack of stretch does put you in more direct contact with the fish, but over rough ground it does have a tendancy to become frayed and then, with no indication, give way on the retrieve, even when not snagged.

You pay your money, take your choice ;)

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 3:52 pm
by FishingFreakJack
prawnster wrote:In my (limited) experience, and I have fished with both, braid is better for bite detection and the lack of stretch does put you in more direct contact with the fish, but over rough ground it does have a tendancy to become frayed and then, with no indication, give way on the retrieve, even when not snagged.

You pay your money, take your choice ;)

I agree and the braid digs into the mono shock leader so the shock leader knot is then weaker

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:04 pm
by Panther2856
Hiya prawnster, Nice to meet you :D

thankyou for your advice, I think I will get some 18lb red ice mono :D


tight lines,


Panther2856

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:06 pm
by Panther2856
Hiya FishingFreakJack,

thankyou for your braid knot advice, I think I will get some 18lb red ice;


tight lines,


Panther2856

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:10 pm
by Panther2856
Hiya benh,

Cheers mate, I'll get the 18lb red ice as you advised, a reviewer for it on said it has good abrasion resistance;



tight lines,


Panther2856

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:52 pm
by tatch1
If your braid is cutting you leader fella you aint using the proper knot for the job try a modified albright that will solve your problem dont know anyone who"s had a failiure through it yet not one i use it boat fishing too & have never had it cut the mono pull for a break you always get the braid + some leader back every time

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 4:59 pm
by svenbren
tatch1 wrote:If your braid is cutting you leader fella you aint using the proper knot for the job try a modified albright that will solve your problem dont know anyone who"s had a failiure through it yet not one i use it boat fishing too & have never had it cut the mono pull for a break you always get the braid + some leader back every time

;) spot on tatch1 If your braid is cutting you leader fella you aint using the proper knot for the job try a modified albright ;)

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Fri Oct 01, 2010 4:06 pm
by FishingFreakJack
svenbren wrote:
tatch1 wrote:If your braid is cutting you leader fella you aint using the proper knot for the job try a modified albright that will solve your problem dont know anyone who"s had a failiure through it yet not one i use it boat fishing too & have never had it cut the mono pull for a break you always get the braid + some leader back every time

;) spot on tatch1 If your braid is cutting you leader fella you aint using the proper knot for the job try a modified albright ;)

I have got to admit my shocky knots are not the best but a behn said braid is pricey

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Fri Oct 01, 2010 5:18 pm
by svenbren
I have got to admit my shocky knots are not the best but a behn said braid is pricey[/quote]


it is but outlasts mono by years .braid is ideal for spinning and boat fishing ;)

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Fri Oct 01, 2010 5:30 pm
by Panther2856
Hiya :D

All this information is Brilliant,


Thankyou,


Panther2856

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Fri Oct 01, 2010 6:40 pm
by FishingFreakJack
svenbren wrote:I have got to admit my shocky knots are not the best but a behn said braid is pricey

it is but outlasts mono by years .braid is ideal for spinning and boat fishing ;)[/quote]


Yea as there is no stretch so you are in contact with bait/artificals. But you dont need to use a shock leeder with the two methods you have mentioned

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Sat Oct 02, 2010 2:19 pm
by FishingFreakJack
benh wrote:
FishingFreakJack wrote:
svenbren wrote:I have got to admit my shocky knots are not the best but a behn said braid is pricey

it is but outlasts mono by years .braid is ideal for spinning and boat fishing ;)

Yea as there is no stretch so you are in contact with bait/artificals. But you dont need to use a shock leeder with the two methods you have mentioned


some people still put a small section of 40lb leader on for spinning[/quote]


You can but not neccesery if fishing with a light rod

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Sat Oct 02, 2010 6:49 pm
by tatch1
the small section of leader used for plugging & spinning is to keep your trebles from damaging your braid should you experience any tangling

Re: Braid and Monofilament question,

Posted: Sat Oct 02, 2010 7:02 pm
by FishingFreakJack
tatch1 wrote:the small section of leader used for plugging & spinning is to keep your trebles from damaging your braid should you experience any tangling

Ah you learn something new every day :)